What Are Some Eyeliner Alternatives?


You are ready to head out to a party or an event, and you suddenly realize that you are out of eyeliner. What do you do? You thought you had some eyeliner that would last you a little bit longer than it did. But, you do not have any at all. It is not unusual to fall into a sticky situation because you will not necessarily look at your makeup inventory before going to an event or party. That is, if you are incredibly busy juggling work, family, home responsibilities, and more. The good news is that there are alternatives you can substitute for eyeliner. And these alternatives work! Let’s go over some of these eyeliner alternatives if you do not have any.

Use Mascara As An Eyeliner Substitute

If you are out of eyeliner but have plenty of mascara, there is good news! You can use mascara to take the place of eyeliner by doing two things. You can use the mascara to fill your eyelashes more than you usually would, or you could gently use it to touch the eyelid. Of course, you would have to be gentle by doing that. Therefore, it may be better for you to fill your eyelashes up and make them look great. If you have waterproof mascara, that is even better. The last thing you would want to happen is to wear more mascara than usual because you do not have eyeliner and end up hearing a sad story. Or you are going to a movie with a tragic ending. That will get the waterworks going, and you will have stains of mascara streaming down your face.

Therefore, if you don’t have waterproof mascara, it may be better to use it by slightly touching the eyelid. But, of course, if you are going to a movie that you know will make you cry. You could still have some smudging, but it won’t be as bad as it would be if you used too much mascara on your eyelashes.

A Makeup Pencil Works Well As A Substitute For Eyeliner

You can use any makeup pencil whether it is an eyebrow pencil or lip liner, you can use that as an eyeliner substitute as well. However, when you clean it off, ensure that you do so carefully, so your eyes do not end up getting in the way. That would be extremely painful. However, if you do not like the color of your lip liner and you do not have an eyebrow pencil, you can stick to the mascara idea if you would like. It is messier than using lip liner or an eyebrow pencil. However, there is another idea that you can utilize as a substitute for eyeliner – listed below.

You Can Use Eyeshadow

Why not use the obvious makeup – your eyeshadow as a substitute for eyeliner. But how can you do that since it can be challenging to apply as an eyeliner? However, that is easy to do. All you need to do is mix some of your eyeshadow with a little bit of water or petroleum jelly, like Vaseline. Then, take a makeup brush and begin applying the mixture to line your eyes, and it will look like you have eyeliner. The nice thing about this solution is that it is straightforward to clean. It may end up somewhat messy if you have an itch and you need to scratch, however.

Use False Lashes

If you do not like these ideas as eyeliner replacements, you can always use false lashes. False lashes will provide you with that elegant appearance to the point that you do not need eyeliner. In addition, you do not have to worry about any eye makeup at all, which includes mascara. False lashes are straightforward to put on, and they are just as simple to remove. That is why that is a great option and a great alternative to eyeliner. You can buy them for a low price at your local drugstore or box store. You should have them as a backup in case you are out of any eye makeup!

Can You Use Household Products As Eyeliner Alternatives?

The short answer to that is no. So the best thing to do is to stick to the recommendations listed above. At one time, a common eyeliner alternative was using crayons or colored pencils. People would dip colored pencils in water and use them as eyeliner. The recommendation is not to use them. Even though, according to Crayola, crayons and colored pencils are non-toxic, the intention is never to use them as makeup. That means if you have a child that accidentally eats a crayon, there is no need to take them to the emergency room. However, at the same time, crayons do not go on the skin. The wax in crayons could cause some irritation which is not something you want.

Therefore, if you have a child and are looking at their box of crayons to use as eyeliner, don’t do it. The same goes for sharpies or pens. Do not use ink as a replacement for eyeliner. You don’t have to worry about ink poisoning, and if the ink were a severe issue, there would be no such thing as tattoos. The ink would stay on the superficial layer of your skin. However, you would end up smudging around your eyes, and you would not be able to clear it out entirely for three weeks.


There are several reasons that you would want to look for an eyeliner alternative. Sometimes you don’t like eyeliner, or you are out of eyeliner and need to find a substitute. The good news is that you can use mascara, eyebrow pencils, or lip liners as substitutes. You can even use eyeshadow mixed with water or Vaseline and apply it with a makeup brush. So there are options you can use to create a good alternative. However, as tempting as it may be, the recommendation is not to use crayons, sharpies, pens, or colored pencils as eyeliner substitutes. That is because the components in those items do not belong on your skin.