Best Hypoallergenic Mascara in 2020 [Buying Guide]

Last updated: July 10, 2020
Published 1:28 am

NaturLash Mineral Mascara

Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

EASY ON THE EYES Sensitive Eye Mascara

Published 1:28 am

Show Contents

Hide Contents

Content

If you were to ask most people to name their top 3 most preferred body organs, the list would probably include the eyes. They are vital organs because they allow us to see the world around us, and as such, they should be taken care of specially. Over the years, women have used several beautification materials, and some of these materials were specially designed for the eyes. However, because of the importance of the eyes, these materials had to be produced in a way that doesn’t harm the lady using it. Even with these precautions, some eyes were just naturally hyper-sensitive, and they couldn’t withstand the harshness of these materials. As time went on, beauty product manufacturers started to come up with good solutions that allowed women with sensitive eyes to wear makeup without fear of irritation and allergies. Nowadays, women can purchase hypoallergenic products and use them comfortably.

The mascara is one of the beauty products designed for the eyelashes, and the best way to make sure that your eyes don’t react when you use mascaras is to purchase one with a hypoallergenic designation. Buying hypoallergenic mascaras allows you to beautify your eyelashes without any fear of subsequent irritation. This buying guide has been put together to help you make an informed decision about which product is right for you. Enjoy!

The Best Hypoallergenic Mascara Reviewed

Below are some of the best hypoallergenic mascaras and their reviews.


1

NaturLash Mineral Mascara

As far as hypoallergenic mascaras go, this one comes close to perfect. This mascara is 100% organic because it was made from natural botanical products, and it doesn’t contain harsh ingredients such as dye, preservatives, lead, petroleum, gluten, paraben and the rest. This means that you can avoid your eyelashes falling out due to toxic ingredients and also the skin irritation that may occur as a result of these ingredients. Using this mascara gives you silky smooth, thicker and longer eyelashes, and it lasts very long. Due to its hypoallergenic properties, this product can be used by people with sensitive and dry eyes and also by people who wear contact lens. This product was made in Canada under cruelty-free conditions. This product has been used by customers around the world who jointly agree that it is definitely worth the buy. Check out the features!

Key Features:

  • Water-resistant
  • 100% organic
  • Hypoallergenic; suitable for people with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Non-toxic; Free from harsh ingredients
  • Produced in a cruelty-free environment
  • Made in Canada
  • For external use only

Specification:

  • Brand name: Fifth & Skin
  • Color: Black
  • 100% organic
Pros
  • Enjoy longer, thicker and smoother lashes when you apply this mascara
  • It can last very long; it doesn’t run easily and is resistant to tears
  • It can be easily washed with a little soap and water
  • Suitable for people with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers thanks to its hypoallergenic properties
  • Doesn’t contain harsh ingredients
  • Continued use nourishes eyelashes over time.
Cons
  • It might be a little gummy when coming out of the tube

2

Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

Well, the fact that this mascara was made by Neutrogena says a lot about the quality of the product. This product is made from natural ingredients such as vitamin E, rice protein and olive oil that help to strengthen and lengthen your eyelashes so that they can reach their full potential. Because of its unique formula and composition, this product is suitable for people with sensitive eyes and contact lens users. This healthy mascara is also dermatologist and ophthalmologist approved. It comes with a soft and gentle bristle brush, and the makeup is easy to remove.

Key Features:

  • Made from vitamin E, rice protein and olive oil
  • Comes with a soft bristle brush
  • Dermatologist and ophthalmologist approved
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens users
  • Smudge-resistant
  • For external use only

Specification:

  • Brand name: Neutrogena
  • Color: Black
  • 21-ounce tube
Pros
  • Continued use of unique formula keep your lashes nourished.
  • This product doesn’t smudge, clump or flake when being used.
  • Approved by medical experts and therefore suitable for people with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • Easily remove this mascara with soap and water or the Neutrogena eye makeup removal
  • Easy to apply thanks to its soft bristle brush
Cons
  • It is not 100% organic

3

EASY ON THE EYES Sensitive Eye Mascara

This product is described as easy on the eyes for a reason. If your eyes are extra sensitive, then you should consider checking out this product. However, it is essential to note that this product is not 100% organic, and it may contain some ingredients which your natural body physiology does not agree with. Once you check through and you don’t recognize any elements that you are allergic to, then it would be a good buy. This product also contains natural waxes and clays that nourish and strengthen the eyelashes. After applying this product, you can be sure that it won’t smudge or flake. The application process in itself has also been made easier due to its specially designed brush. Another added advantage of this product can be washed off easily when you decide to do so. Even though it stays on all day, little soap and water will do the trick.

Key Features:

  • Utilizes a hypoallergenic formula; suitable for sensitive eyes and people who wear contacts
  • Fragrance-free
  • Long-lasting; doesn’t smudge
  • Creates good looking eyelashes
  • Easy to use application brush
  • For external use only

Specification:

  • Brand name: Beautify Beauties
  • Color: Black
Pros
  • Compatible with sensitive eyes and contact lens users
  • Easy to apply thanks to its easy to use application brush
  • Continued use nourishes and refreshes your lashes
  • Lasts very long; doesn’t smudge
  • Easy to remove
Cons
  • It is not 100% organic.

4

4D Silk Fiber Eyelash Mascara

Though this product possesses all the characteristics that make a hypoallergenic mascara good, two distinct features make it even more appealing to potential users. The first feature is the black pigmented effect that it has on your eyelashes, and the second is that it can last all day. Though these look like regular features, they are more defined when using this product. Even though it is not 1000% organic, this product is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. However, if irritation occurs at any point, please stop use. Its gentle formula also allows for the continued nourishing, strengthening and lengthening of your lashes.

Key Features:

  • Gentle formula; suitable for all skin types.
  • Deeply colored.
  • Long-lasting.
  • Easy to apply and also easy to remove.
  • For external use only.
  • Smudge-resistant.

Specification:

  • Brand name: Tetyana Naturals
  • Color: Black
  • Soft bristle brush
Pros
  • Lasts very long; up to 18 hours. You no longer need to worry about smudges and the likes
  • The advanced formula allows for a fuller and longer lashes.
  • Deeply colored so your eyes can look more defined and beautiful
  • Easy to apply and also easy to remove
  • This mascara is waterproof and tear-resistant
Cons
  • It is not 100% organic

5

Telescopic Original Mascara

Another fantastic product from L’Oreal Paris. This product is tailor-made for those looking for longer and fuller eyelashes above other reasons. This mascara uniquely separates lashes and makes them lengthier. This product is also ophthalmologist tested, and it is suitable for people with mild allergies, sensitive eyes and contact wearers. This formula is very smooth and therefore allows for easy application. This mascara is also fragrance-free, and it doesn’t clump. It goes well with other L’Oreal Paris makeup products. However, what you have to hold on to is the fact that this product increases the length of your lashes up to 60% longer.

Key Features:

  • Longer lashes; up to 60% lengthier.
  • Flexible dual precision brush.
  • Smooth formula; easy to apply.
  • Dermatologist tested; suitable for people with sensitive eyes and contact wearers.
  • Long-lasting; up to 16 hours
  • For external use only

Specification:

  • Brand name: L’Oreal Paris
  • Size: 0.27 ounces
  • Color: Washable blackest black
Pros
  • Get fuller and longer eyelashes when you use this mascara; up to 60% longer
  • Ophthalmologist tested; Suitable for sensitive eyes. You no longer have to fear mascaras because of allergies.
  • Comes with a flexible dual precision brush that allows you to apply the mascara easily.
  • Smudge resistant; lasts up to 16 hours
  • Performs a lash by lash operation on your eyelashes
Cons
  • Needs to be applied in a calm environment

6

FULL ’N SOFT Mascara

If you are looking for a very affordable hypoallergenic mascara that will suit your needs perfectly, then this is probably the right choice for you. This washable mascara contains vitamin E, which creates healthier and fuller eyelashes. It also utilizes an advanced thickening formula which allows for exceptionally smooth and silkier eyelashes. Its quick dissolve system will enable you to take it off quickly at the end of your day, and it is also ophthalmologist tested and approved for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes. All these fantastic features and more can be optimized within the first three months of purchase and use of this product. After this period, you are advised to change your mascara or run the risk of it constantly clumping and getting infected with bacteria.

Key Features:

  • Utilizes an advanced thickening formula which contains vitamin E.
  • Quick dissolve system that allows it to remove mascara easily.
  • Clump-resistant.
  • Suitable for people with allergies and sensitive eyes.
  • For external use only.

Specification:

  • Brand name: Maybelline New York.
  • Color: Washable Black.
  • 0.48 ounces.
Pros
  • Contains vitamin E that nourishes the eyelashes and makes them fuller and longer.
  • Can be easily removed due to its quick dissolve system.
  • Ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
  • Doesn’t clump or glob.
  • Very affordable
Cons
  • Cannot be used for more than three months

7

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Mascara

One thing that stands out about this product is the fact that it was made with 100% natural ingredients, including jojoba oil and glycerin. This product doesn’t utilize harsh elements and is free of paraben, petrolatum or synthetic fragrances. Another unique thing about this product is its Black Brown color which makes it compatible with any eye color. This mascara also lengthens your eyelashes and makes it fuller. The combination of the formula and its unique application brush creates long-lasting makeup and softly nourished lashes. This product has been tested and approved by medical professionals and is suitable for sensitive eyes and people who use contact lens.

Key Features:

  • It is made from natural ingredients, including jojoba oil and moisturizing glycerin.
  • Ophthalmologist approved and safe for sensitive eyes and contact wearers.
  • Long-lasting definition.
  • Does not contain harsh ingredients.
  • Cruelty-free.
  • The tube comes with a brush.
  • For external use only.

Specification:

  • Brand name: Burt’s Bees.
  • Color: Black-brown.
  • 0.48 ounces.
Pros
  • Made from 100% natural ingredients; therefore, you don’t have to worry about reacting to harsh products.
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Dermatologist approved.
  • Easy to apply and equally easy to remove.
  • Works with all eye colors and skin tones due to its black-brown color.
  • Lasts long
Cons
  • Its is not tear-resistant.

8

Almay Thickening Mascara

As the name suggests, this mascara specializes in giving you thicker and fuller eyelashes. It does this without creating clumps, flakes or smudges. This product was manufactured by Almay, which says a lot about its quality. In addition to all these beautiful features, this mascara is also infused with aloe and vitamin B5, which helps to condition and nourish the eyelashes. This product is also hypoallergenic, which means that it can be used by people with sensitive eyes and even people who wear contact lens. It also helps that this product is ophthalmologist tested and approved. The specially designed brush creates a unique effect when used to apply mascara. Take a closer look at this product, and it just might be what you are looking for.

Key Features:

  • Creates fuller and thicker eyelashes.
  • Ophthalmologist approved; hypoallergenic, suitable for sensitive eyes and contact users.
  • Uniquely designed application brush.
  • It is infused with aloe and vitamin B5.
  • Fragrance-free.
  • Cruelty-free.
  • Very affordable product.
  • For external use only.

Specification:

  • Brand name: Almay
  • Color: Black
Pros
  • You can be sure of thicker eyelashes when you use this product. Gives you that full, lush, high-volume look.
  • It is infused with aloe and vitamin E that nourishes your lashes and makes them look smoother and silkier.
  • Non-smudging and non-flaking; can last for a very long period.
  • Easy application due to its uniquely designed application brush.
  • Suitable for people with sensitive skin types; ophthalmologist and dermatologist tested.
Cons
  • Does not wash off easily

9

Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara

Unlike the rest of the products on our reviews, this product comes in a 2 in 1 package. It contains both a lash primer and mascara which work together to give your lashes that lush length, volume and definition. This product is also very easy to apply due to its specially formulated brush which goes through every lash to give you that distinct look. This product is also made without harsh ingredients like paraben, paraffin, silicone, synthetic fragrances and the likes which cause people to react. Produced under cruelty-free conditions, this hypoallergenic mascara is designed to suit people with sensitive skins and contact lens wearers. It is also dermatologist and ophthalmologist approved.

Key Features:

  • 2 in 1 product. Mascara and lash primer
  • Dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested; hypoallergenic, suitable for sensitive eyes.
  • Specially molded application brush
  • Free of harsh ingredients
  • Cruelty-free
  • Long-lasting.
  • Varied packaging
  • For external use only

Specification:

  • Brand name: Honest beauty
  • Specially molded bristles
  • 0.2 fluid ounce
Pros
  • This product comes in a 2 in 1 package; mascara and lash primer.
  • Easily create a full, lush look with intensified color.
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens users; hypoallergenic product tested and approved dermatologist and ophthalmologist.
  • Treat every lash with its specially designed application brush.
  • It is made without harsh ingredients that irritate the eyes.
  • Does not clump
Cons
  • Might be a little challenging to work at first try.

10

2020 4D Silk Fiber Mascara

This product comes last on our list because it is relatively new. This product was launched earlier in 2020 and has not yet been tested by a wide range of customers. However, the reason why it made it to our list is because of the fantastic offers this product gives and the affordability of the product. This product is a set containing a mascara and an eyeliner, both of which are hypoallergenic and works perfectly for people who have sensitive eyes, are allergic or use contact lens. This product is also designed to stay on for an extended period; up to 24-hours. Waterproof and tear-resistant, this mascara will not smudge even if you sweat a lot. It is also effortless to apply and wash off too. If your skin doesn’t react to new products, you should give this product a try.

Key Features:

  • 2 in 1; Product contains mascara and eyeliner.
  • Waterproof lengthening.
  • Hypoallergenic; suitable for people with sensitive eyes.
  • Long-lasting; can stay up to 24 hours.
  • It is made from natural, non-toxic ingredients.
  • Easy to use and easy to remove.
  • Flexible brush head.
  • 100% money back if the product doesn’t serve your needs.
  • For external use only.

Specification:

  • Brand name: 4D Silk Fiber
  • Color: Black
  • 2 in 1 package
Pros
  • Get your mascara and eyeliner all in one place and look fabulous.
  • Long-lasting; can stay up to 36 hours.
  • Cn is used by people with sensitive eyes and contact lens users.
  • Easy to use and also easy to remove.
  • Utilizes natural, non-toxic ingredients, so your skin doesn’t react unnecessarily to harsh substances
  • 100 per cent money-back guarantee if you don’t like the product
  • Quick-drying and gives your eyes an in-depth pigmented look that will leave you looking beautiful all day.
  • This product is waterproof and smudge resistant.
Cons
  • This product is new and has not been used by a wide array of customers.

Buying Guide Questions

Selecting a skin product that works for you perfectly might seem like an arduous task. This guide has been put together to help you make a well-informed decision about which product you might want to get. If you are still not sure about which hypoallergenic mascara to use for your sensitive skin, then answering these questions will go a long way in clearing your doubts and helping you finally decide what is right for you. Enjoy!

Is there a mascara for extremely sensitive eyes?

There is a mascara for sensitive eyes. For extremely sensitive eyes, however, you would need to consult your dermatologists to know just how extremely sensitive your eyes are and if they would accept mascara.

Why do my eyes get irritated when I wear mascara?

It could be for several reasons. Probably the product you are using is not compatible with your skin in which case you should try another or you are applying it the wrong way. Consulting a beauty care expert might help you pinpoint what the problem is.

How do I know if I am allergic to mascara?

If you begin to notice irritation or redness of eye after or during the time you use your mascara, then you are probably allergic. Allergies, however, can be traced to a single ingredient. When you find out what this ingredient is, then you can look out for it and avoid when next you buy a mascara.

Can you wear mascara if you have blepharitis?

You can, but you have to be sure which product you are using.

Conclusion

It is good to look beautiful and attractive when you step outdoors and having sensitive eyes or skin shouldn’t stop you from using beauty products. If you use the appropriate hypoallergenic mascara and follow the user’s instructions, you would be able to put on beautiful makeup just like any other lady out there. This buying guide was put together to help you make the best decision.

Above is the list of some of the best hypoallergenic mascaras you would find on the market. If you have seen something you like (which is more than likely), do further research, read customer reviews, and then get the product. The opportunity to find something that can serve your needs in the long term doesn’t come very often, take advantage of this one and order something that is right for you.